State power over a supplier’s components
Confrontato fra 2 giurisdizioni
In Germania
The BMI can prohibit a manufacturer’s critical components — and an appeal does not suspend it
The Bundesministerium des Innern may prohibit the use of a manufacturer's critical components by operators of a kritische Anlage where their use would likely impair public order or the security of the Federal Republic. The prohibition may be extended to further components of the same manufacturer and the same type, and may be made binding on all KRITIS operators. Read the procedural sting: Widerspruch und Klage haben keine aufschiebende Wirkung — challenging the prohibition does not buy you time to keep operating the component.
Quando: Triggered by a prohibition, not by a calendar. The practical duty is to be able to answer one within days rather than months.
Sorge quando
- The KRITIS duty overlay: five duties that size alone never triggers
Che aspetto hanno le evidenze
- A manufacturer and component inventory good enough to answer a prohibition — which manufacturer, which components, where deployed
- A replacement path for each critical component, with a realistic lead time
In Polonia
Be able to answer a *dostawca wysokiego ryzyka* decision — and to withdraw what it covers
Where the Minister for Digital Affairs declares a supplier to be a *dostawca wysokiego ryzyka*, three things follow. You may not put the covered ICT products, services or processes into use, with immediate effect. You must withdraw them from use within seven years of publication in *Monitor Polski* — four years for telecoms undertakings, for items on the Annex 3 list of critical network and service functions, a ten-item list mapped to 5G/3GPP components (AMF/AUSF, UDM, baseband and radio, UPF, SMF, PCF, NSSF, NRF, NEF, SEPP). And entities under the Public Procurement Law may not purchase covered items at all. Read the decision carefully: it names product, service and process TYPES rather than imposing a blanket vendor ban, and it extends to the supplier’s whole capital group. Whether any decision has issued must be queried live in *Monitor Polski* and the Ministry’s BIP — this pack hard-codes no vendor and no decision.
Quando: Prohibition on putting into use: immediate. Withdrawal: seven years from publication in *Monitor Polski*; four years for telecoms undertakings on the Annex 3 functions.
Che aspetto hanno le evidenze
- A supplier, product and component inventory detailed enough to answer "do we run anything of this type from this group?" in a day
- For telecoms: a mapping of your network functions onto the Annex 3 list
- A dated record of the last check of *Monitor Polski* and the Ministry’s BIP